Homeschool or Old School? Debunking the Myth of the Unsocialized Homeschooler


Unsocialized Homeschoolers fishing on a weekday morning

I answered the door at dad’s house. We were having some work done so the kids and I were there homeschooling for the afternoon.  A woman was at the door. As I walked out with her to explain what needed to be done, she looked back and saw my three kids standing there very curious but politely watching. “Why are you all out of school today?” She asked with a nice smile. My 9 year old replied, “We are homeschooled.” And that woman’s smile turned into a snide “Oh!” She turned and gave me a quick dirty look and then face changed back to an appropriately polite face   After all – I would soon be writing her a check for $380.

You see this stuff happens all the time – and thanks to the mass populous my kids are aware of it too.  I mean – how many of you had your school choice be the brunt of a joke in Horton Hears A Who?  “He is pouch schooled.”

After last week’s post – I had a handful of people in our community and strangers online who contacted me. Most of them were parents with autistic kids. Most of them said their autistic kids had no friends.  One mom said, “She is tolerated at school, but does not have friends”.  One parent said, “He has never had a friend and is in high school now. How did your son have a different experience? ”

So I had to think about that. It’s difficult to answer any questions about spectrum kids because they are all so different.  There is no standard one size fits all. However I definitely can see patterns in the friendships my son has built.  Most of his friendships come from our homeschool community.

Yes homeschoolers – those unsocialized children.  It’s funny; the only time I hear the term “unsocialized” is in reference to dog training or homeschoolers.  I really think Tim Hawkins is the most entertaining when taking about those unsocialized homeschoolers. But I digress…

Let me paint a picture just to lay this whole idea of the “unsocialized homeschooler” to rest … We homeschoolers are crazy social.  We have our own field trips (and we have a lot of them). We have park days, holiday parties, library times.  And then there are these days:

Mom A: “I can’t do it today- it’s not working and I am about to loose it!”

Mom B: “Oh we aren’t getting anything done. Want to come over and let the kids jump on the trampoline?”

Mom A: “Be there in 15 minutes!”

I do take advantage of a homeschool program. My kids basically go to school one day a week. They have classes with licensed teachers and even have the whole lunch room/ recess experience there. My social extrovert daughter has tons of friends there   My autistic son has none.  So clearly – just being a homeschool kid does not mean you become friends with my son.

Unsocialized Homeschoolers at yet another field trip

Unsocialized Homeschoolers at yet another field trip

Where my son has forged friendships is where families are together building bonds. That’s what homeschoolers do.  Its like we have generated our own community that is not based in man-made schedules or organizational goals.  It is based around mutual experiences and a lifestyle choice that admittedly, feels a bit rebellious most days.  Even the moms get really close. Just the other day, my friend Linda stopped by to drop off something. Two hours later, we were sitting on a couch crying over the shared understanding of losing our mothers recently to cancer. Our kids were off playing and deepening their own friendships.

And, these friendships cross age, sex, religious, and cultural barriers. Boys and girls play together. It is nothing to see an eighth grader running off to push a 5 year old on a swing. Kids don’t form clicks around cultural or religious barriers. Do they have disagreements and misunderstandings at times? Sure. Do you see stuff like the girl drama you see at school – no!

But, I know many parents can’t homeschool.  So what are the truths I can take from the friendships my son has built and how can that be used to help autistic kids form friendships in their own community?

This is where church comes in; because he has forged friendships there too. And while churches are a different kind of community, they also tend to build communities where families connecting to other families are the core. Again, divisions between ages and sexes are not so pronounced and the churches I have been a part of valued diversity.

So what is it? What factors lead to those friendships?  Authentic, familial community groups – I feel like many of our kids, even the non-autistic ones need connections to their communities through more groups like these. Groups where they are valued as individuals and contributors. Groups where they are surrounded with multiple adults who care about them. Groups where adults can model to kids how we care for, value, and respect all individuals.

I shared this with a friend who said, “Oh you mean like in the past – Old School like? Small communities that care for their members.” Maybe that is what it is. Maybe my homeschool community and my church community give me two small communities within the larger one that my family can connect to. And so, today, my heart is full of gratitude for my homeschooling community and my church community for valuing not only my children – but me as well.

7 thoughts on “Homeschool or Old School? Debunking the Myth of the Unsocialized Homeschooler

  1. Great post! My mother homeschooled my sisters and me while we were in the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd grade for one year. This is when we homesteaded in Alaska and had no consistent means of getting to school every day. This was in the late 50’s. We didn’t have the opportunity of being social with other homeschoolers because of the area we lived in. The next year when we went to a public school I remember fitting right in though. I believe you have to be a special person to be able to homeschool your children. It’s not for everyone. Keep up the good work!


  2. Erin, it is always a pleasure to to read your blogs & see a small bit of your insight. Thank you for sharing with the world; your children are truly blessed to have you as I’m sure you feel truly blessed to have them! When I stop to think about what kind of influences I want my children exposed to, your family would be first on my list! Homeschooled or not, they would enrich the lives of my boys via the choices you’ve made for them & the experiences they’ve all had with you! Society has always looked down their long noses at things they are ignorant and/or uninformed about which is a shame as anyone with eyes can see that your children armed with their education will enter said society as young adults far more equipped to deal with it than most are. Thank you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s